2005 Buffalo Nickel Errors: Spear Grazed Bison Guide

Buffalo nickel error value

2005 Buffalo Nickels

2005 Buffalo nickel errors and varieties are collectible coins.  For instance, observe a rare struck-through string 2005 S proof buffalo nickel error coin. 

This struck through string error coin occurred as a piece of string came between the die and the planchet while the nickel was struck. 

Did you know that some collectors only collect coins with struck through string errors?  This increases the value of rare buffalo nickels.

buffalo nickels errors

Furthermore, the string randomly spreads across the planchet.  Observe the small fibers visibly protruding from the struck through area.  

Moreover, these fibers are tiny, and often only seen with a microscope or coin loupe. – Sullivan Numismatics Inc.  Also look for the 2005 buffalo nickel speared bison!  

Furthermore, hunt for other buffalo nickels such as the 2005 buffalo nickel with a detached leg,

Misprinted Buffalo Error Coins

Strike through coin errors happens when another object comes between a blank and a die at the time of its striking.  In other words, struck through error coins occur when a piece of foreign material or even another coin comes between the die and a planchet during striking. 

five cent buffalo nickel

2005 buffalo nickel errors are extremely rare and a favorite of many coin collectors to obtain.   They’re so scarce because of the unintentional strike.  Moreover, various materials that coins are struck through consist of staples, string, cloth, screws, or even other coins. – ngccoin.com

2005 Buffalo Nickel Value

Furthermore, Bison nickels don’t have to be an error or variety to be valuable. For instance, a 2005-S 5C Bison DCAM (Proof) coin graded PRDCAM70, sold for $546.00.

five cents buffalo coin

Furthermore, a 2005-D Bison nickel graded MS67, sold for $750.00.  Moreover, a 2005-P 5C American Bison Nickel graded MS66, sold for $1,125.00.




However, a 2005 D Five Cent Speared Bison graded MS66, sold for $2,650.00 in 2021. Therefore keep watch for a Speared Bison specimen in pocket change! Look for a die gouge on the bison. 

2005 bison nickel
Westward Journey Buffalo Nickels

Did you know that there are coin apps you can download to your phone that can help you identify and value your coins too? Learn more about how to make a fortune with coins here.

This website is a partnered associate and may contain affiliate links. Full disclosure is available here.  Check out the buffalo nickel price chart below.

2005 Buffalo Nickel Error Values

2005 American Bison Nickel Estimated Error Values

Note: Values are estimates based on market condition and grade.

Error Type Description Estimated Value Range
Speared Bison A die gouge running through the bison's back/body. $50 – $500+
Die Cracks / Cuds Raised metal lines or blobs caused by die failure. $5 – $50
Off-Center Strike Design struck off-center on the planchet. $50 – $200+
Missing Clad Layer Partial loss of the outer metal layer. $100 – $300